Proudly serving Sayville and the surrounding areas

Eli Pizzeria - logo

Willie is here from Luchese,

same great food!

Sorry, we are closed due to the fire in deli next door, we will reopen soon! Thank you for your patronage.

Pizza Calzone Pizza with brocolli

Eli Pizzeria uses only

the freshest ingredients

to prepare meals.

 

 

Delivery is available! Call today.

631-244-3600

Pizzas

Regular Slice

$2.55

Sicilian Slice

$2.65

Specialty Slice

$4.25

Large Cheese Pie

$12.95

X- Large Cheese Pie

$15.99

Sicilian Pie

$15.95

White Pie

$22.99

Baked Ziti Pie

$22.99

Broccoli White Pie

$22.99

Buffalo Chicken Pie

$23.99

Chicken, Bacon and Ranch

$23.99

Grandma's Pie

$15.99

Chicken Marsala Pie

$23.95

Everything Pie

$23.95

with meatballs, sausage, ham, pepperoni

Veggie Pie

$23.99

Mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, peppers, and black olives

Chicken Cutlet Parm Pie

$23.95

Eggplant Parm Pie

$22.95

Salad Pie

$22.95

Tomato and Basil Pie

$22.95

Honey Mustard Chicken Pie

$23.95

Chicken Francese Pie

$23.95

Toppings:

Meat toppings

Full Pie $4.25

Half Pie $3.25

Sausage, meatball, pepperoni

Veggie Toppings

Full Pie $4.25

Half Pie $3.25

Peppers, fresh tomatoes, basil, eggplant, onion, green olives, black olives, mushrooms

Extra Cheese

Full Pie $4.50

Half Pie $3.50

Chicken

Full Pie $6.50

Half Pie $4.00

Anchovies

Full Pie $6.00

Half Pie $4.00

Pineapple

Full Pie $6.50

Half Pie $4.00

Bacon

Full Pie $7.00

Half Pie $4.00

Ham

Full Pie $6.50

Half Pie $4.00

Roasted Peppers

Full Pie $6.00

Half Pie $4.00

We use real bacon

Calzones

Plain Calzone

$6.95

Meatball

$8.95

Pepperoni

$8.95

Sausage

$8.95

w/ Eggplant

$8.95

w/ Extra Mozzarella Cheese

$1.00

w/ Extra Ricotta Cheese

$1.00

w/ Chicken

$8.95

w/ Spinach

$8.95

w/ Broccoli

$8.95

Rolls

Sausage and Peppers

$8.99

Sausage

$7.99

Chicken

$7.99

Chicken w/ Mushrooms

$9.95

Spinach

$8.95

Broccoli

$8.95

Pepperoni

$8.95

Meatball

$8.95

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$8.95

Buffalo Wing Roll

$8.95

* Prices are subject to change.

Garlic Knot Pie

$17.99