Proudly serving Sayville and the surrounding areas

Eli Pizzeria - logo

Willie is here from Luchese,

same great food!

Sorry, we are closed due to the fire in deli next door, we will reopen soon! Thank you for your patronage.

Pesto Panini Alfredo


Eli Pizzeria is a

family owned restaurant.


Delivery is available!

Call today.


We also have whole wheat and Gluten Free Selection

(for an Additional $2.00)

Served with Bread, Spaghetti, Rigatoni, Linguini, Cappellini - and Fettuccine, Gnocchi, Tortellini or Cavatelli

(for an Additional $2.00)

Add a Dinner Salad for an Additional $3.50

Ala Vodka


With bacon and onions in a pink cream sauce



In a white cream sauce with a dash of cheese

Clam Sauce


White or Red



Sautéed bacon, onions, and peas in a white cream sauce

Al Pesto


Homemade pesto sauce tossed with fresh ground pignoli nuts, aged parmesan cheese and Italian seasonings


Any hero $1 extra for parm



Sausage and Peppers


Sausage and Mushroom


Sausage and Eggs






Chicken Cutlet



Peppers and Egg


Potato and Egg


Italian Hero


Grilled Chicken Cutlet


w/ lettuce, tomato and onion

* Prices are subject to change.