Proudly serving Sayville and the surrounding areas

Eli Pizzeria - logo

Willie is here from Luchese,

same great food!

Sorry, we are closed due to the fire in deli next door, we will reopen soon! Thank you for your patronage.

Cannolis Cannoli

Dessert Menu

The staff at Eli Pizzeria has

over 25 years

of experience.



Delivery is available! Call today.


Fresh Made Cannolis (Large)

$3.50 each


(6) $3.50

(12) $6.49

Stuffed Zeppoli

$1.95 each

(with Cannoli Cream, Chocolate or Raspberry)

(Sold 4 or more)

Extra Sugar


Rainbow Cookies

$1.25 each

Fresh made in the traditional Italian style

* Prices are subject to change.