Proudly serving Sayville and the surrounding areas

Eli Pizzeria - logo

Willie is here from Luchese,

same great food!

Sorry, we are closed due to the fire in deli next door, we will reopen soon! Thank you for your patronage.

Lasagna Shrimp scampi Meatballs

Our 1/2 tray serves 5 - 8 people and full tray serves 10 - 15 people.

 

Check out our coupons to save money on your meal at Eli Pizzeria! Visit us today.

158 Lakeland Avenue

Sayville, NY 11782

Eli's Pizzeria Catering Specials

Package #1: 20-25 People Save 30% $135.99 + tax

  • Full tray of Baked Zitti

  • 1/2 tray Chicken Cutlet Parmesan

  • 1/2 tray of Sausage and Peppers

  • 1 tray of House Salad

  • Includes free bread

Package #2: 20-25 People Save 40% $155.99 + tax

  • Full tray of Penne or Rigatoni Ala Vodka

  • 1/2 tray Chicken Marsala

  • 1/2 tray of Eggplant Rollatini

  • Full tray of House Salad or Caesar Salad

  • Includes free bread

Package #3: 20-25 People Save 35% $165.99 + tax

  • Full tray of Rigatoni Bolognese

  • 1/2 tray Chicken Marsala or Francese

  • 1/2 tray of Meatballs

  • Full tray of House Salad or Greek Salad

  • Includes free bread

Package #4: 20-25 People Save 35% $179.99 + tax

  • Full tray of Penne or Rigatoni Ala Vodka

  • 1/2 tray Chicken Francese

  • 1/2 tray of Sausage and Peppers

  • 1/2 tray Antipasto

  • 1/2 tray of Eggplant Parm

  • Includes free bread

American and Italian Hero $19.99 per foot

*Above packages can be customized to your liking. Please call for more information.

1/2 Tray Serves 5-8 People

Full Tray Serves 10-15 People

APPETIZERS

1/2 TRAY / FULL TRAY

Fried Calamari

$50.00 / $90.00

Baked Clams Oregante

$50.00 / $90.00

Mozzarella Sticks

$35.00 / $65.00

Mussels Marinara

$45.00 / $75.00

Stuffed Mushrooms

$45.00 / $85.00

Eggplant Rollatine

$50.00 / $90.00

Chicken Fingers

$55.00 / $95.00

Garlic Knotts

$1.00 each

SALAD

1/2 TRAY / FULL TRAY

Add Chicken to any Salad

$20.00 / $35.00

Tossed Salad

$35.00 / $55.00

Antipasto Napoletano (Cold)

$50.00 / $95.00

Homemade Mozzarella and Tomato

$55.00 / $95.00

Caesar Salad (Dressing On The Side)

$45.00 / $75.00

BAKED DISHES

1/2 TRAY / FULL TRAY

Baked Ziti

$45.00 / $90.00

Stuffed Jumbo Shells

$45.00 / $90.00

Baked Ravioli

$45.00 / $90.00

Lasagna

$55.00 / $95.00

Any Pasta With The Following Sauces:

1/2 TRAY / FULL TRAY

Alla Vodka

$50.00 / $95.00

Broccoli, Oil and Garlic

$50.00 / $90.00

Bolognese

$55.00 / $95.00

Primavera Red or White

$45.00 / $85.00

Tomato Sauce

$45.00 / $85.00

Marinara

$45.00 / $85.00

Aglio and Olio (Garlic & Oil)

$45.00 / $85.00

Red Clam Sauce

$55.00 / $95.00

White Clam Sauce

$55.00 / $95.00

Alfredo

$45.00 / $85.00

SUGGESTED ENTREES

1/2 TRAY / FULL TRAY

Chicken and Mushrooms With Red Sauce

$55.00 / $90.00

Chicken Parmigiana

$55.00 / $95.00

Chicken Francese

$55.00 / $95.00

Chicken Cacciatore (Boneless)

$55.00 / $98.00

Chicken Marsala

$55.00 / $95.00

Chicken Rollatine (Marasala Wine Sauce and Mushroom)

$55.00 / $100.00

Shrimp Parm

$60.00 / $110.00

Shrimp Scampi

$60.00 / $110.00

Eggplant Parmigiana

$50.00 / $90.00

Sausage and Peppers

$50.00 / $95.00

Meatballs In Sauce

$55.00 / $95.00

* Prices are subject to change.

Save Money on Your Meal with Our Coupons

(Click the coupon to download and print)

friday2

Buffalo Wings

$45.00 / $85.00

Monday-Special-Coupon Tuesday-Special-Coupon Wednesday-Special-Coupon Thursday-Special-Coupon Sunday-Special-Coupon Deal-1-Coupon Deal-2-Coupon Deal-3-Coupon Deal-4-Coupon Deal-5-Coupon Deal-6-Coupon Deal-7-Coupon Deal-8-Coupon Deal-9-Coupon Deal-10-Coupon Deal-11-Coupon Deal-13-Coupon Deal-14-Coupon Deal-15-Coupon Deal-12-Coupon