Proudly serving Sayville and the surrounding areas

Eli Pizzeria - logo

Willie is here from Luchese,

same great food!

Sorry, we are closed due to the fire in deli next door, we will reopen soon! Thank you for your patronage.

Fried Calamari Greek salad Buffalo Wings

Add chicken to your salad for an additional charge of $3

or add shrimp for an additional charge of $5!


The staff at Eli Pizzeria has over 25 years of experience! Call today.



Baked Clams (6)


Topped and baked with seasoned bread crumbs

Fried Calamari


Golden fried calamari served with a side of homemade marinara sauce

Mussels Marinara


Served in a homemade marinara sauce

Mussels Luciano


Steamed and sautéed with shallots, garlic and a touch of wine in a

white sauce

Mozzarella Sticks


Served with a side of tomato sauce

Chicken Fingers


Stuffed Garlic Knot (12)


with Mozzarella and Pepperoni (...$1.00 each)

Jumbo Rice Ball


Served with side of sauce

Buffalo Wings


Served with blue cheese

Cold Antipasto


Bed of mixed greens, with salami, prosciutto, provolone, fresh mozzarella, soppersata, and roasted peppers

Stuffed Mushrooms


Stuffed with vegetable stuffing

Fried Calamari Arrabiata


with Cherry Peppers


Your choice from the grill add chicken $3.00 / Shrimp $5.00

House Salad


Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, olives and carrots served with house dressing

Caesar Salad


Romaine lettuce tossed with a Caesar dressing and Romano cheese

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato


On A Bed Of Mixed Greens

Greek Salad


*$1.00 extra grated cheese*


Sausage (3) or Meatballs (3)


Sauteed Spinach


Rice Ball (1)


Sauteed Broccoli in Garlic and Oil


Garlic Bread


Garlic Bread with Mozzarella


Steak Fries


Garlic Knots (6)


Garlic Knots (12)


* Prices are subject to change.

Chicken Fingers with Fries